SATURDAY JAN 28, 2023
×
Search AeroXplorer
ECONOMY COMPARISON: United Airlines Long Haul vs. Short Haul

ECONOMY COMPARISON: United Airlines Long Haul vs. Short Haul

BY ADAM SCHUPAK 12/29/2022 AGO 0 COMMENTS

United Airlines is one of the 3 major premier airlines in the United States and lately, the airline has made a number of history-making decisions, one of the most recent and notable being the largest aircraft order in U.S. aviation history. That being said, a big question comes to mind. Just how good is United's economy class? More specifically, what is the difference between the short/medium-haul and long-haul economy class products on offer?

 

Photo: Dylan Campbell | AeroXplorer

 

For the sake of simplicity, this article will compare only United's new economy class products on their mainline (short/medium haul - A320/737) and wide-body (long haul - 757/767/777/787) aircraft, with the exception of the 757 of course not strictly being a widebody.  

 

SIDE NOTE: The name of the aircraft in each category is irrelevant, as the economy class products on United's narrowbody planes tend to be homogenous. The same can be said for its widebody aircraft as well. 

 

*Mainline - Smaller planes that fly routes like Newark - Miami or Newark - Denver

*Widebody - Larger planes that fly routes like Newark - Amsterdam or San Francisco - Tokyo

 

Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Cabin Atmosphere and Space - Mainline 

 

Most of United's newly delivered mainline planes (mainline in this case referring to planes with a capacity of 100 seats or more and non-subsidiary) feature cabin mood-lighting that is actively controlled by the cabin crew. The space underneath the seats is more than adequate in most cases as well as the overhead bins. This may become problematic if you've boarded a full flight. These features make even United's older (such as A319s or A320s) and more cramped aircraft (737-700, -800, -900) feel modern and spacious. A commodity that is slowly disappearing from airlines in general, regardless of class, is air vents. For now, all mainline aircraft - be the plane newly delivered or 20 years old - have air vents.

 

The mood lighting (typically kept blue), can help calm the nerves of first-time or nervous flyers. Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Photo: Adam Schupak


 

Cabin Atmosphere and Space - Widebody 

 

The cabin atmosphere on United widebody aircraft tends to feel more cramped and stuffy on the Boeing 777 due to its seat configuration (3-4-3 instead of the standard 3-3-3), as well as a lack of air vents and mood lighting. However, this is probably due to the age of these planes, as their seats have been modernized and the cabin renovated (configuration-wise). While it made sense to modernize the cabins onboard, there most likely was not a huge incentive for United to spend extra money adding colorful lights to a 20-year-old plane. There is more storage available underneath the seats and in the overhead bins due to the general extra space onboard a long-haul aircraft. 

 

United's POLARIS seat with individual air vent offered. Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Photo: Adam Schupak

 

In terms of general cabin atmosphere, you'll find that United's mainline aircraft have an overall better experience for both those shorter and slightly lengthier flights as compared to their widebody counterparts, despite the average flight on a United mainline aircraft lasting an average of 3.5 hours less than on a widebody. 

 

Now let's shift our focus from the atmosphere onboard to the seat experience.

 



ADVERTISEMENT

 

Seat Experience - Mainline 
 

United's mainline planes (A320/737 families) have a universal 3-3 economy class configuration, allowing for 6 seats per row. Each seat has 30 inches of pitch, not including Economy Plus. All of the planes in United's mainline fleet are equipped with Wi-Fi while only United's Boeing 737NG and MAX aircraft are equipped with power outlets. Much like the other two large U.S. carriers, you can stream free movies and TV Shows courtesy of the airline through the onboard Wi-Fi, which comes online after the aircraft ascends through 10,000 feet. Only United's 737NG and MAX aircraft have device holders below the literature pocket, allowing passengers to watch their movies or TV shows comfortably. 

 

 

United Economy B737. Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Device holder in United Economy. Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Below-seat power outlet. Photo: Adam Schupak


 

Seat Experience - Widebody 

 

The overall seat experience is quite similar to what you get on United's mainlines, as the seat-backs on both types of planes are made of leather and have adjustable headrests. All widebody planes in United's fleet have 13.3-inch fast response-touch IFE screens, power outlets, and the same amenities as the mainline economy product. If you don't prefer to use the IFE screen to watch movies, you can still use your personal device to stream the same movies and TV shows available on the IFE system to your device. There is no phone holder due to the IFE system being present. All widebodies are also equipped with Wi-Fi, which again works above 10,000 feet. 

 

IFE screen - Boeing 757/767/777/787 families of aircraft at United. Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Leather seat-back design on United 777-200ER. Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Same leather seat-back design on United 737 MAX  as on United 777-200ER (mainline compared to widebody). Photo: Adam Schupak

 

Space + power outlet underneath seat - United 777-200ER 


 

Results: United Mainline

 

 Wi-FiPower OutletsIFE ScreenSeat Pitch 
A319YesNoNo30" - Economy
35" - Eco Plus 
A320YesNoNo30" - Economy
 35" - Eco Plus 
737NGYesVaries 
(Depends on Type)
 
Varies
(Depends on Type)
30" - Economy
35" Eco Plus  
 
737 MAX YesYes No 30" - Economy 
35" - Eco Plus 

 

Photo: Tyler Giersdorf | AeroXplorer


 

Results: United Widebody

 

 Wi-FiPower Outlets IFE Screen Seat Pitch 
757-2/300Yes Yes Varies 
(Depends on type of cabin and aircraft) 
757-200: 
31" - Economy 
37" - Eco Plus 
757-300:
30-31" - Economy
34-38" - Eco Plus 

 
767-3/400Yes Yes Yes 767-300ER: 
31" - Economy 
34-43" - Eco Plus 
767-400ER 
31" - Economy 
35" - Eco Plus 
777-2/300ER Yes Yes Yes 777-200/300ER 
31" - Economy 
34" - Eco Plus 

 
787-8/9/10Yes Yes Yes 787-8/9/10
31" - Economy
34" - Eco Plus 


 

The overall design of United's mainline and widebody seats are quite similar to each other, but of course have some major differences, such as the lack of power outlets on the A320s. Hopefully, you found this guide helpful - let us know if you'd like to see more just like it!

Adam Schupak
Adam Schupak is a member of the AeroXplorer staff team, writing articles and contributing to their podcast - Aerospace by AeroXplorer. Adam is interested in anything public transport related and is currently training to become a glider pilot.

Comments (0)

Add Your Comment

SHARE

TAGS

INFORMATIONAL economy comparison eco ecoplus economyplus united widebody narrowbody mainline a320 a319 b737 737 737-700 737-800 737-900 737 MAX

RECENTLY PUBLISHED

Attending an Aviation University in the US: The Pros and Cons If you have been considering attending an aviation university in the United States, then you know the decision is complex. While it provides you with specialized training and networking opportunities, it is a heavy responsibility. INFORMATIONAL READ MORE »
From Baggage Allowance to Lounge Access: Your Flight Benefits with British Airways If you ever had questions regarding your flight benefits on an upcoming British Airways flight, here is a one-stop guide to your baggage allowance, lounge access, and Executive Club benefits all in preparation for your next BA trip. INFORMATIONAL READ MORE »
TSA PreCheck vs CLEAR: Which is Better? Travelers at airports often regard security as a big nuisance, as they have to wait for upwards of an hour at a time to get bags screened. Domestic U.S. airports in the last few years have introduced new ways of making this process faster, notably through programs like TSA PreCheck and CLEAR. These are in the realm of "Trusted Traveler Programs," where a traveler establishes their permanent credentials ahead of time so queuing at the airport is reduced. INFORMATIONAL READ MORE »


SHOP

$2999
NEW!AeroXplorer Aviation Sweater Use code AVGEEK for 10% off! BUY NOW

FOLLOW US ONLINE